This is a review of Maggie Reilly's album
Elena.
For technical data see
Angel Tears
by Merciful Squirrel.´
If you love sad and beautiful songs, Elena
is for
you. It's more
diverse than the two former albums. Besides few fast pop songs it
contains several moody songs with very special beautiful melodies --
and more.
When I first heard Elena, I got the impression that the soundscape is
cold somehow. Perhaps it's just because the disk is blue.
Besides Maggie's voice there are several instruments: distorted guitar,
muted trumpet and others at the upper midrange. Between them and
the bass there is a gap at the lower midrange most of the time
producing image of coldness. Sometimes the distorted guitar is
filtered or processed in such a manner its pitch is shrouded,
especially at the lower range. The guitar's remarkable melodic
ideas will not always come through. Thanks to the diversity,
these are no concern with all the songs, however. The sound scape
is crystal clear. The reverb creates space, but the dose of the
reverb varies between songs.
To start from the end, As Darkness
Falls is compound of Maggie's voice with generous reverb and
some
piano, that's all. The song is so beautiful it hurts.
Maggie's whisper "goodnight" at the end has a tremendous power.
To France is a modern version of Mike
Oldfield's song. There is a chance to endless argumentation about
which one of the two To Frances is better. Elena's sound is
full-bodied and rich while original's is rough and wild. I like
it when Mike plays with the reverb when Maggie sings "by the lamp's
flicker" in the original version. There are some differences in
the lyrics, too. I'm quite sure, Maggie sings "far from the
highland" in Elena, while the original says "islands", but you must
listen to it by yourself. If I had to introduce Maggie to
somebody who has never heard anything, I would play To France instead
of Moonlight Shadow or Everytime We Touch. But which To
France...just can't decide.
Maggie sings He
Moved Through The
Fair
accompanied by only the reverberation of Lyndhurst Church: a
cappella. She controls the song serenely and without
exaggeration. Do I need to mention, a cappella is no mean feat by
a singer. Especially if you end up showing no weakness.
Listen
To Your Heart and Syonia
are
rapidly running pop songs. They could make a great hit under
lucky
conditions -- and no big hits have ever made without luck. Listen
To Your Heart is more straightforward. Please, could you play the
dist guitar one octave lower and select the sound good for that range
to reduce the blue sound scape. Syonia comes from "sayonara",
farewell. I once read that Maggie was unsure of this song because
of some irregular chords, perhaps. No way! This is a great
song. It's not based so much on melody, rather it builds a
texture of instruments and Maggie's voice developing it towards a minor
whirlwind of triple time bass beats. Breaking the rules is
acceptable as long as your thing works.
The title song Elena,
too, relies
on texture rather than melody. The irregular rhythm and the
expressive acoustical bass give color to this lyricless song.
Fast running song in minor key create a yearning mood.
Värttinä adds some ethnic spice.
Torn
Between Lovers starts with an
acoustical guitar intro. Could we have more of this guitar in the
other songs, too, to fill the lower midrange gap. A meditative
song of difficulty in decision.
Finally, I have to mention that You
Brightened Up The Darkness is built up of an incredibly
beautiful song
melody.
If I haven't mentioned your favorite song here, I still like it.
There are so many great songs of different nature I just run out of
words. Besides that beautiful voice, besides her phenomenal
skills as singer, Maggie also has the ability to find exceptional
melodies to sing.
Elena was published in 1996. This review was
written in July 2004.
Back to Maggie
This
page set is about my paintings. Most of
the text is in Finnish language, but ... just enjoy the pictures!
Risto Latva
Start of the Paintings (in Finnish)